Solar panels, heat pumps and insulation in Broomhall conservation area
In the Broomhall conservation area (Sheffield), external wall insulation needs planning permission, and so does an air source heat pump on a wall or roof facing the road; one at the back or side, internal and loft insulation and solar panels on a roof slope normally do not. The area has 24 listed buildings; on a listed building solar panels and heat pumps are not permitted development at all and need planning permission and listed building consent. 410 homes inside the boundary have an energy certificate: 42.2% are solid-wall homes with no wall insulation, 63.4% heat with a gas boiler and 43.4% are rated D–G; 1 has a heat pump. EPC register November 2026; rules as at 21 October 2026.
Data: EPC register November 2026 (latest certificate per home), conservation area boundaries 3 November 2026, permitted development rules as at 21 October 2026 · calculated 5 November 2026 · Methodology and sources
410homes with an energy certificate
42.2%solid walls, no insulation
63.4%heated by a gas boiler
1heat pumps
Article 4: Sheffield does not publish Article 4 areas on planning.data.gov.uk — check with the council.
What needs planning permission in Broomhall
Work (house, not listed)
In a conservation area
Rule
Air source heat pump on a wall or roof facing the road, or nearer the road than the house
Planning permission needed
Part 14 Class G, G.1(j)
Air source heat pump at the back or side (outdoor unit up to 1.5 m³, MCS Planning Standards, one per house — two on a detached house)
No permission needed (permitted development), unless an Article 4 direction removes it — check with the council
Part 14 Class G
Solar panels on a pitched roof (up to 0.2 m proud, not above the ridge)
No permission needed (permitted development), unless an Article 4 direction removes it — check with the council
Part 14 Class A, A.2(c)
Solar panels on a wall, balcony or roof enclosure facing the road
Planning permission needed
Part 14 Class A, A.2(e)
Solar panels on a flat roof (up to 0.6 m above the roof)
Prior approval of appearance from the council, unless an Article 4 direction removes it — check with the council
Replacement windows and doors of similar appearance
No permission needed (permitted development), unless an Article 4 direction removes it — check with the council
Part 1 Class A, A.3(a)
Listed buildings: 24 in the area (grade I: 0, II*: 1). The table is for houses that are not listed: on a listed building, solar panels and air source heat pumps are not permitted development at all (they need planning permission), and any of these works needs listed building consent.
Flats: 71% of the certified homes here are flats or maisonettes. Homes in a block of flats have no householder rights for alterations; heat pumps and solar have their own, tighter rules for blocks of flats.
The homes in the area (latest certificate per home, n = 410)
Walls
Homes
Share
Solid wall (brick or stone), no insulation
173
42.2%
Cavity wall, unfilled
81
19.8%
Modern wall (U-value from the design)
54
13.2%
Cavity wall, insulated (as built or unspecified)
51
12.4%
Solid wall, internal insulation
18
4.4%
Timber frame
14
3.4%
Solid wall, insulated
9
2.2%
Cavity wall, filled
6
1.5%
Cavity wall, partly insulated
4
1.0%
Heating
Homes
Share
Gas boiler
260
63.4%
Communal heating
82
20.0%
Electric (storage heaters, panels, boiler)
67
16.3%
Heat pump
1
0.2%
Loft / roof insulation
Homes
Share
No insulation
60
14.6%
Under 200 mm
27
6.6%
200 mm or more
57
13.9%
Insulated (depth not recorded)
46
11.2%
Flat or other home above
194
47.3%
Other
26
6.3%
Windows
Homes
Share
Double glazed
378
92.2%
Single glazed
30
7.3%
Secondary glazing
2
0.5%
CDE
Energy rating: A 1 (0.2%) · B 25 (6.1%) · C 206 (50.2%) · D 108 (26.3%) · E 55 (13.4%) · F 11 (2.7%) · G 4 (1.0%). Houses and bungalows: 29% of the homes; solar panels on 0.5% of the certificates. Most common build period on the certificates: before 1900. Designated: 2 September 1970.
Compared with Sheffield and England
Share of homes
Broomhall
All 32 areas in Sheffield
England
Solid walls, no insulation
42.2%
28.0%
48.7%
Gas boiler
63.4%
47.6%
66.4%
Rated D–G
43.4%
—
56.5%
Caveats
Certificates describe a home when it was assessed; 50% of these are from 2020 or later (latest 28 October 2026). “No insulation (assumed)” is the assessor's default for older walls.
The rules are England's national permitted development rules (General Permitted Development Order 2015, Schedule 2, as at 21 October 2026). They do not cover building regulations or a council's own conditions. This is not a planning decision: ask Sheffield if in doubt.
Boundary: Sheffield City Council via planning.data.gov.uk (entity 44006568, reference 5434, 31.5 ha). Homes are placed by the coordinates of their UPRN (OS Open UPRN); addresses are not shown.